Selkirk hurdle

From Wikipedia
The Poughkeepsie Bridge ca. 1978. Its loss required an even longer detour for freight trains coming to New York City from the southwest.
New York Central Railroad map from 1929 shows the Water Level Route avoids major elevation changes

The Selkirk Hurdle is the term used by urban planners, railroad employees, politicians, and others to describe the route that must be taken by freight trains traveling between New York City and other points in downstate New York that are east of the Hudson River, and locations in the United States to the south and west. There are no rail freight bridges or tunnels that cross the Hudson River south of Selkirk, which is 10 miles (16 km) south of Albany and the home of Selkirk Yard, a major CSX classification yard. As a result, trains from Long Island and New York City (except for the borough of Staten Island which has a rail bridge to New Jersey) must travel 140 miles (230 km) north to cross at Selkirk before continuing on their way. [1] Advocates claim that this detour and the inefficiencies that result force New York City to rely more heavily on relatively inefficient trucks than most parts of the United States, where freight trains are more common. However, at least for traffic to and from the west, this route was touted for its efficiency as the "Water Level Route" by the New York Central Railroad because trains using it did not have to climb over the Appalachian Mountains, and it is still used by the New York Central's successor, CSX, for traffic to both sides of the Hudson River.

To cross the Hudson, trains must use the Alfred H. Smith Memorial Bridge or another bridge further north near Mechanicville, New York, operated by Pan Am Southern railroad. A 1974 fire ended service across a railroad bridge at Poughkeepsie, 85 miles or 137 kilometers north of New York City. [2] Because of the height of the bridge, trains still had to travel west to Maybrook, New York and back, limiting its use when it was in service. Although the bridge at Poughkeepsie still stands, the rails have been removed and it became Walkway Over the Hudson State Historic Park in 2009.

The only alternative to the Selkirk Hurdle is for rail cars to be floated across Upper New York Bay, an operation run until 2006 by the New York Cross Harbor Railroad, and currently by New York New Jersey Rail, LLC, now owned by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. The Port Authority is investing in improvements to its decayed infrastructure, much of which was washed away by Hurricane Sandy. As trucking has become more prevalent, rail float operations across the bay have dwindled over the decades from 600,000 cars per year to 1,600 cars per year. [3] The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey hopes some day to transport as many as 25,000 cars annually. [4]

Eliminating the Selkirk Hurdle is a primary objective of the Cross-Harbor Rail Tunnel proposed to span Upper New York Bay between Brooklyn and either Jersey City, New Jersey. A draft environmental impact study for the project was released in November 2014. [5]

See also


  1. ^ "USING BARGES TO REVIVE A RAIL ROUTE", The New York Times, May 4, 1986. Accessed January 3, 2008. "That is because in recent years virtually all rail traffic between Brooklyn, Queens, and Long Island, at one end, and points south, at the other, has traveled over the Selkirk Hurdle, a 280-mile (450 km) loop that extends up the eastern bank of the Hudson River to a bridge at Selkirk, New York, near Albany, then down the western side of the river."
  2. ^ The Beacon Line by Pierce Haviland
  3. ^ Cross Harbor Freight Movement Draft Environmental Impact Statement, p. 1-2
  4. ^ Barry Newman (2012-05-20). "New York's Last Cross-Harbor Railway Chugs On as Alternative to Trucks: Barges Float Boxcars Into Town, Sludge Out; Cocoa Beans at the Bottom of the Bay". The Wall Street Journal.
  5. ^ Cross Harbor Freight Movement Project

Further reading